Send Feedback

picture-1

From DailyKos.com:

Newsweek brings you the five biggest lies of the health care debate. These are whoppers so big that anyone should be embarrassed to be associated with them. But these lies didn’t originate from some obscure quarter, and they’re not being spread over the backyard fence. Here’s a quick look at the Big Lies, and just a few examples of how the top names on the right are willing to bathe in BS if it helps their funders in the insurance industry.

1. You’ll have no choice in what health benefits you receive.

If you read the bill – Title I, Subtitle E, Sections 141-143, on pages 41-48 – it turns out that the Health Choices Commissioner’s job is, essentially, to make your health choices for you. … The so-called “Health Choices Commissioner” will be the closest the United States has come to having an absolute ruler since King George III.
– Heritage Foundation

2. No chemo for older medicare patients.

After he was diagnosed with brain cancer more than a year ago, Sen. Kennedy had excellent care, including surgery and chemotherapy, before he died last week. … In the future, will a man of Kennedy’s age, with brain cancer but without the means of offsetting his own healthcare costs, be kept alive, operated on, given chemotherapy — by a government obsessed with cutting healthcare costs? Rationed care is coming, and the death panels will not be far behind.
– Pat Buchanan

3. Illegal immigrants will get free health insurance.

The National Council of La Raza and the Congressional Hispanic Caucus pushed to include illegal immigrants in the president’s healthcare effort. Despite statements to the contrary, the Obama administration could force the American people to pay for the healthcare of millions of illegal immigrants in the U.S.
– Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Texas)

4. Death panels will decide who lives.

The America I know and love is not one in which my parents or my baby with Down Syndrome will have to stand in front of Obama’s “death panel” so his bureaucrats can decide, based on a subjective judgment of their “level of productivity in society,” whether they are worthy of health care. Such a system is downright evil.
— Sarah Palin
In Oregon, the law permits doctors to assist in the suicide of terminal patients who wish to end their lives. Let us assume numerous patients have Alzheimer’s and, so, cannot be part of the decision to end their lives. Who then makes the decision to continue or end life? Would it be unfair to call the decision-makers in those cases a death panel?
– Pat Buchanan
“I think that’s a legitimate point. You don’t have to call it death panels if you don’t want to. You can call it a panel. I call it rationing.”
– Michael Steele

To read the full list, click here.

RELATED:

OPINION: Time For Obama To Get Tough On Healthcare (Us, Too)

OPINION: Lou Dobbs, Lobbyists & Lynchmobs United Against Obama

Tags: GOP, Healthcare, Michael Steele, Pat Buchanan, Sarah Palin
Recommend to friends!
  • BlackPlanet
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • email

News One Links

 
  • http://www.blackplanet.com/LaShortyz/ LaShortyz

    The only thing wrong with this article is that the facts were not provided.

  • http://newsone.com/obama/opinion-why-americans-ignore-obama-on-healthcare/ OPINION: Why Americans Ignore Obama On Healthcare | NewsOne

    [...] OPINION: 5 Biggest Healthcare Lies Told By The GOP [...]

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/teddyrr/ teddyrr

    I agree exactly

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Stardune/ Stardune

    You see BP families, they want you to turn on the president like a pack of wolves. Now their money for things have to come out of their pockets (Lier Elephants and Those suppose to be black haters) yes we have a plenty of them that will stand up against Obama and his group that will make mistakes. And as for Pastor Manny, Juan Williams, Larry Elders, Rev Jesse Paterson that are suppose to be black, if there is something you don’t like with YOUR BIG CONNECTIONS why don’t you try to get a friendly meeting with someone from the Obama camp instead of blowing out crap with trying too see if both parties can improve on health care-schools-umemployment. By the way what has any of them done with helping a person that is homeless-childcare-paying for a person to be seen with money that has come out of their pockets and not given to some group that helps people like that. And I mean walk up to them and say here this is for you. No there are not enough Democrates that do that either, but you start from A to get to C.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Stardune/ Stardune

    No Lashortyz, I’am from MD where Mr. Steele is from and the only thing he has done for the poor black’s was to come to an events and smile for the camera’s real pretty. If I had to rate him on his performance then he would 95% out of 100%. Yes we all have are cross to bear but lets give him his do? he did try to get the Republicans to be updated and not from the pass. Unless you live in MD and can saw the per centage of good work that party has done for blacks-latinos and other races that are here correctly then let us know.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/gls209/ gls209

    Alright?? You list the “5 biggest healthcare lies”, so what are the 5 “real healthcare truths” to refute these “biggest lies”?? I’m looking and looking for the “facts” and I don’t see any laid out in this article. Since the article is from the Daily Kos, I can understand why there are no accompanying “facts”. Daily Kos hates America, thus the “one sided” posting.

    How did Juan Williams get on the “Obama Haters List”?? He’s one of the biggest Obama supporters there is. Let’s get this straight!! Obama is not “HATED”, it’s his POLICIES!!!!!! We want the man’s POLICIES to FAIL!!!!!! If Obama and the politicians won’t get on this so-called “health plan”, why should you or I?? If it’s all that good, they should lead the way. DON’T FALL FOR THIS HYPE!! …

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/birddawg2001/ birddawg2001

    The only real thing wrong with this story is the headline. These are not llies. Look at any other health care system like the one that Nobama is pushing and you will see that you have no real choices, and the death panel is just part of the system. Some states have it already. Get your facts straight. go to mybuyweb.com

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Papa-Jon/ Papa-Jon

    It’s refreshing to see most people actually respond to this article with common sense, rather than the usual “Obama can do no wrong” dribble you normally read. Most of you get it – this is NOT a Black and white issue. It’s the policies we question. Some of this requires a little more knowledge of the bill that’s being proposed.

    Of course there is no verbiage in the current bill regarding “death panels”. There are however provisions for “end of life” counseling – which is the foundation for such a “death panel”.

    Look – it’s not rocket science. Look at Social Security. You get to pay into the system your entire life, and to get a penny when you retire you have to plea your case in front of a judge to receive your benefits. Statistically we know that the elderly consume the majority of the health-care costs. When this program spirals out of control with excessive spending, where are they going to make the first cuts to control it? I don’t want to be 65-70 and have some govt bureaucrat decide if my hip replacement is going to be financially viable.

    Look at the “cash for clunkers” fiasco. It was pitched as a $1 Billion dollar stimulus deal, and turned out to be $5 Billion. The only automakers that were “stimulated” were foreign automakers because US automakers (aside from Ford) didn’t have models that qualified for the incentive. Both GM and Chrysler reported record low sales (17-20% deficit) while only Ford shows a 15% increase in sales as a result of the plan.

    What makes health care any different? The core of the problem of our current health care system isn’t being addressed in the newly proposed bill – and that is to control the cost. As long as hospitals can charge $25 for an aspirin and throw in some ambiguous lab fees that no one can decipher – it is going to be an orgy of corruption and greed. I agree that a reform is needed and some cost control needs to be put in place – but not a govt “option”.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/kenwillb4u/ kenwillb4u

    Papa-Jon, I can’t believe that you are that stupid. The Healthcare reform that The President is promoting has nothing to do with a “death panel” They alreay have “end of life counseling”, now the government will pay for it under the same law as before. How could you even think that the USA would kill their own elderly? What policies that you people don’t like that The President is initiating? He is just trying to fix what 8 years of the Bush regime broke. Where were you when Bush was writing his own constitution? I hope that the Attorney General send them to jail. I believe that you people really are not listening to him as much you are listening to Rush L, Glenn racist Beck, Hannity and Bill O’reily, oh of course Fox/lying news.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Papa-Jon/ Papa-Jon

    @ kenwillb4u – exactly what govt health care program did Bush ‘break’? We are discussing health care right? You may chose to treat this Dem vs Rep argument like a football game – but I am critical of any president or party that’s trying to pull the wool over my eyes. Still waiting for those 40 acres and a mule are you? Well if the govt says it – it must be true – right? Grow up.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/ur2slo4me/ ur2slo4me

    @ Pap-Jon
    Medicare Adantage is what the Bush Administration broke while it was a good ideal It went un funded and caused bigger deficit from the medicare fund. He actually cut revenue into the Government with his Tax cuts. Thats how Bush broke the medicare system.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/ur2slo4me/ ur2slo4me

    There were Blacks who were against freeing the slaves. We called them Uncle Toms. I believe there are those with the same mentality today hidden behind whatever cause or agenda they like to portray but the truth remains the same they are happy with the status quo they are living well so dont mess with their prosperity. If you do as well as I’m doing then I guess it makes me less special? Others are plain ole racists and then there are some that have truely ideological differences and even others with idealogical differences mixed with racsism. I believe racsism exasperates the healthcare debate or anything that President Obama does. I maybe wrong but I dont think im the only one who believe this.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/branecia/ branecia

    All these haters are full of it-they need prayer and God donot like ugly and this is an ugly thing-people against people for what? all this hatred brings back decades of you haters not for the good but for the wrong-I hope these haters make it into hell for they will burn-no one liked bush but all his lies passed w/o a wimp of haters, no all these haters are pathetic & I wish they would all go away and stop acting like dumb idiots and get a life or something on their mines-why do we not want our people to succeed what is your problem? it’s all in God’s plan let him decide what is best for he does have the last word-or do these haters believe in God the way they are acting I think not-because it is not my worry or problem look in the mirror and ask yourselves why do I hate & why am I scared and of who? this is wrong for people like these to even exist I bet if it was a klansman you still would be talking that same noise and getting no where, just keep on stooping low like you are and see where that will get you,these comments are ridiculous and wrong peoples mines are not working properly these days,you are against anything or anyone who is not for your no nonsense words- I hope this reform passes and be what you thought it would not be helping those who donot have insurance and it is not for ilegal immirgrants either get that straight now,lies are spreading and you are believing them what will you believe next?,people get real and believe that God will see PRESIDENT OBAMA thru. Dag the man is only been in office 7 months give him a chance like you gave Bush but he bushed wacked the who U.S. and left us in a pure mess oObama is trying to change and now you don’t want it changes after 8yrs of torture you still want the same for yourselves I want change and change for the better & I believe MR.PRESIDENT will do just that for the better. I donot see a problem but you haters do what a shame. Believe what you want and hate who you want in the end you will have to answer to someone.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/branecia/ branecia

    Papa john who gave u that name? pitiful should be the name-you have your info dead wrong you need to get a life and do your home work for truely you have not-you mean nothing to any party so your comments or worthless, for you donot know the truth if you read it and you haven’t-.you are just wolfing at the mouth like them other haters & you need to just go away and get the facts for you have them not, anyway this reform bill will pass and their is nothing you can do about it.so just deal with it. ? do you have health insurance do you know anyone who doesn’t and should this is what my President is trying to get-you should be greatful you have any insurance if you do gave any hopefully you will keep yours and if the republicans have their way be sure you will not have it long for it will rise where you can’t even afford it at all, so be greatful you can afford it now rather than not at all-make sure you use it for you will need it at some point and you may not have it & the wawy the president is doing is to make sure everyone is insured how can you be against that but you are what a sad case you are.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/branecia/ branecia

    ALL these haters need not apply- this is not worth responding to anymore it’s over and it’s a “wrap” so get over it.I’M OUT.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/bigj97216/ bigj97216

    Have any of you checked out who popa-john is? Why are you suprised by his comments? It has been established that the underlying reason for the rabid foaming at the mouth protests and lies about the health care plan is racist/white supremest in nature. White people are angry that we have a Black man in the White House. They lost control of everything else. Their last bastion was the presidency, in their wildest dreams they never would have believed a Black man would beat their boy. Now they will stop at nothing to see him fail. Asshats like Papa-Jon say “it’s his policies not him” but anyone with half a brain knows that is a lie. Cash for Clunkers were very successful but you watch Fox Snews so you would never know Papa-Jon. No one has seen the bills that have been proposed yet you have butt munchers on here claiming it has death panels and other bat-s**t crazy nonsense. Troglodytes like Papa-Jon are incapeable of thinking for themselves, they spew out what ever their masters: druggie limpballs, Beck, Insannity, and the other right wing nutjob racist hatemongers tell them to think. As to the Black detractors, I’ve been told by a couple of old guys who were former KKK members and the swear to me that the were Blacks in the group. They are nothing more than self loathing cretins that go out of their way to show, “I’m not like those other Black people I’m like you white master love me love me”. It does not matter the issue the ignorant racist will fight it. What are you doing here Papa-Jon? Are you a Free Republic freak?

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/SoularFlarez/ SoularFlarez

    #1 healthcare lie = you can eat whatever you want and pills and/or surgery will make it ok

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/adesousa/ adesousa

    I don’t live in America, but it seems the same things is happening everywhere, the government just think they can play god with peoples lives.
    Obama, unfortunately is just doing what those with the moeny finacing everything tells him to, sure he might push through a few radical changes, but at the end of the day, they’re using him. http://www.conspiracyoftherich.com interesting book on finance and a bit about Obama and he’s advisors.

    Whenever you got political party rivalry be aware, they’re all the same basically, its just one party with different factions. What one doesn’t do now, they’ll find another way to bring in.

    You know what the problem is, I’ll tell you. The people of most countries spend their time fighting against each other, Why??? I’ll tell you because the government finds ways to make us pissed off with each other over something. (i.e. look at the face or customer service area of most governmetn departments, the bottom rung. Full of ethnic minorities, some are just grateful to have that job, and they’re used to push through / uphold policy) Some of us look and think, Wow, we’ve come so far…… NO we haven’t, they’ve found ways to get to us, make us think we’ve come so far. The reality is whos above them, whos making all those rules, whos financing the plots? those are the questions we should ask. Instead we fight with other people just like ourselves.

    Remember people, we’re financing them, not the other way round. They are accountable to us, not the other way round.

    I believe that the governmetn need sick people, they need criminals, they need people on support services, only so that they can keep paying the money to themselves.

    SO their only way to survive and flourish and impose more rules, laws etc. is to make sure all the problems perpetuate.

    And that my friends is their only defence, they never want to solve any problems, it doesn’t serve them to solve the problems of the world, cos theen there would be no need for them, and we wouldn’t be their slaves.

    Thats all everyone is, just a slave to their systems…….

    It’s time for the people to rule and decide……

    Why do we need people to make decisions for us?
    We didn’t ask them to dictate?
    Why do they continue to dictate?
    Or did they train us form an early age?
    GO to school get a job, so that you can pay the most tax.
    And teach your children to do the same.
    Thats all they prepared us for.

    Keeping them in the lifestyle they’ve become too accustomed to…

    There are more of us than them, they control all the money…

    IT’s time we took back power,

    Power to the people, but we not going to do it if we fight each other!!
    We need to take them on as a collective.

    They answer to us, not the other way round.

    NO matter what area of our lives, housing, health, finance, education,
    They answer to us.
    Thats it.

    What we should be doing is joining together as human beings

  • http://www.blackinfo.net/?p=5296 Black Info.Net – African American News Hub | Black Info.Net

    [...] OPINION: 5 Biggest Health Care Lies Told By The GOP [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus
?>