Send Feedback

black-law-students-1237

I have a tremendous amount of respect for the sharp young minds of The National Black Law Students Association (NBLSA).   I was the keynote speaker for the organization just over a year ago, along with my good friend Charles Ogletree at Harvard University.  I was impressed with the brilliant legal eagles in the room, and all the potential they possessed.  I was also honored to have the opportunity to speak with them and add a little bit of knowledge to their inspirational talent base.

I was most impressed with Melinda Hightower, a student at The University of Virginia.  Starting from humble beginnings in Detroit, Melinda has gone on to earn an MBA from The University of Chicago, an undergraduate degree from Cornell and was rated as one of the top debaters in the world.  In high school, she picked up nearly a million dollars in scholarship money, which impressed the heck out of me.  Even though she is still in law school, Melinda now works with the National Football League on their collective bargaining agreement, helped to design the NBLSA website, and manages many of the activities of the national organization.

As I listened to Ms. Hightower’s impressive credentials, all I could see was “potential, potential, potential.”  But then I wondered what Melinda and her peers planned to do with all that potential.  I began to wonder what this admirable and empowered organization would do with their ability to change the world.  While Ms. Hightower seemed to share a personal desire to make the world a better place, I am sad to say that most of her peers didn’t share the same sentiment.  Instead, the conversations seemed to drone around who would make the most money at the biggest law firm that has them doing the most meaningless work.  There were parties being planned and conferences being prepared, but almost no conversation about how the NBLSA would put itself on the forefront of important social, racial and legal issues of the day.  I was a wee bit disappointed.

RELATED: Fewer Black Students Being Admitted To Law Schools

When I wrote a recent article about the Innocence Project, an initiative that has been setting prison inmates (mostly black men) free with DNA evidence for several years, I didn’t hear a peep out of the National Black Law Students Association.  When I do my research on the issues that relate to the mass incarceration of African American males, I rarely hear a word from the group.  When I see key civil rights issues on the table that impact the black community, the National Black Law Students Association is almost never involved in the conversation.  Even when there was a recent finding about black students being hit with serious reductions in law school admission, the NBLSA was nowhere to be found .  In spite of the massive historical power of the African American attorney, someone has convinced this powerful group, among others, that their job is to network with each other and prepare themselves to become well-trained tools of corporate America.

All that power, all that potential, all that capability and the students have been convinced to voluntarily commit themselves to social and intellectual castration. I encourage the group to reconsider its position.  The NBLSA doesn’t have to be weak, safe and ineffective, and I argue that when it comes to the NAACP, National Black MBA Association and other collective gatherings of African American professionals, their value should be measured by their meaningful impact on the African American community at large.  Having the “blingingnest” conference, or getting the most money from corporate sponsors (who usually wish to buy your loyalty and tame you) should no longer be the benchmarks.  The Civil Rights Movement did not occur just so we could find a way to fit into a world of lackluster social impotence.

RELATED: Yale Law School Olympian Needs Bone Marrow Donor

I am not here to bash the NBLSA or any other black student organization.  I am here to encourage a new paradigm of thought for the 21st century.  I am not here to tell any student or any group that they shouldn’t get out into the world and make money – that’s usually a strong motivator for students who come from poverty.  I’m a finance professor, so I of all people understand the value of making a dollar.  What I am here to say is that the National Black Law Students Association and other groups like it have been taught to ignore their collective capability and community responsibility in exchange for personal financial prosperity.   They should understand that intelligence without the presence of courage means that you are in danger of spending your life as a high paid slave.  Leaving potential untapped effectively means that you’ll work like a dog, live your life and die without anyone ever knowing that you were here.

For the NBLSA or any similar group, students must be retaught the value of remaining connected to the important issues which affect their communities.  I encourage the leadership to reassess their value to the world, and get cracking on issues that actually matter.  Black people are dying for every day they spend not doing what they are equipped to do, and this should be unacceptable to all of us.

Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.

Tags: Black Students, Education
Recommend to friends!
  • BlackPlanet
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • email

News One Links

 
  • http://www.blackplanet.com/deshawn121/ deshawn121

    why is dr boykin always looking for a army to enforce is racist initiatives?

    no one wants to follow dr boykins because his way of doing things is ineffective and dated.

    every one is finally believing that to make a dent in society and become a person that have some what power you must get a education and work with in the system rather than blasting the system from the outside on a soap box

  • http://law.justtome.com/national-black-law-student-association-analyzed-dr-boyce-watkins/ National Black Law Student Association Analyzed: Dr Boyce Watkins … Law just to Me

    [...] post:  National Black Law Student Association Analyzed: Dr Boyce Watkins … tags: among-the-nominees, boyce, britain, keira-knightley, national-black, nominees, race, [...]

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/c0mplX_symplicti3/ c0mplX_symplicti3

    Ooh, this article hits home because I am a black law student, and partcipate in BLSA at my school. Most students are interested in the law firms, maybe its just culture– Maybe it’s just greed. I am the only black member of a school based non-profit that helps fund summer grants for students doing public interest work.
    Maybe Dr. Watkins, some of us are concerned about paying our student loans back! And, the truth is, many firms are vastly white. So I think instead of chastizing BLSA for seeking firm jobs and not doing public interest work, we should be commending those who are breaking firm barriers and providing black students an incentive to help others– sadly, some of us don’t feel the need to give back.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/CaliFemme23/ CaliFemme23

    deshawn121, Well well…Another INTELLIGENT person not sucked into Dr. Boyce Quackens rigamarole…Good points you made here…

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/moniQTee/ moniQTee

    @ALL COMMENTS

    THE PROBLEM WITH BLACK PEOPLE ONCE AGAIN… YOU NGGAS DO NOT UNDERSTAND ANYTHING ABOUT WEALTH AND ESTATE… THESE SO-CALLED INTELLIGENT BLACK PEOPLE SHOULD BE POOLING THEIR BRAINS TO CREATE THEIR OWN EMPIRES NOT RUNNING BEHIND WHITE PEOPLE ONCE AGAIN EXPECTING WHITEY TO HELP YOUR BLACK @SSES OUT.

    EVERYONE HAS TO START BUILDING FROM SOMEWHERE. WHAT BLACK PEOPLE FROM HERE DONT UNDERSTAND IS *YES* YOU *ARE* STARTING FROM SCRATCH… IT MEANS YOU WILL HAVE TO CREATE BLACK WEALTH IN THIS COUNTRY BECAUSE THESE CRACKERS WILL NEVER GIVE IT YOU. YOU THINK THAT RUNNING TO THEIR LAW FIRM HELPS YOUR BLACK @SS OUT?? NO.

    WHAT IT DOES IS CONTINUE TO SYSTEMATIC DEBASE OF YOUR PEOPLE, NO MATTER HOW MUCH YOU THINK IT DOES NOT.

    THE IDEA IS TO CREATE YOUR FORTUNE AND STOP THINKING THE WHITE MAN IS GOING TO HAND IT DOWN TO YOUR GENERATIONS… YOU ARE SIMPLY THERE FOR ONE PURPOSE….TO MAKE *THEM* RICH, NOT *YOU* RICH. YOU GET A CUT OF THE MONEY BUT WHAT… HOW FAR DOES THAT HELP YOU INVEST? SAY YOU WANT TO BUILD YOUR REPUTATION, BUT DO YOU REALLY LEAVE IN THE END? NO…

    SO IF YOU WANT TO BE ABLE TO HAND DOWN GENERATIONS OF OPPORTUNITY YOU HAVE TO THINK IN TERMS OF CREATING YOUR OWN NETWORK TO BUILD UPON…

    YOU PEOPLE REALLY THINK ITS DUMB LUCK OR AN ACCIDENT THAT THE MAJORITY OF THE WEALTH IN THIS COUNTRY AND ABROAD STAYS IN ONE PLACE???

    ITS *WHO* YA KNOW… PLEASE DON’T THINK THAT WHITE PERSON WILL GIVE YOU THAT JOB OR THAT BREAK OVER THEIR BEST FRIEND’S COUSIN’S NIECE??…*EXACTLY*

    SO THINK BIG… AND THINK FOR THE FUTURE.

    ITS TRUE WHAT THEY SAY… A PIECE OF PAPER DON’T MEAN SHT.. AND MY FAVORITE BUMPER STICKER

    “ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IS NO MATCH AGAINST REAL STUPIDITY.”

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/_A_/ _A_

    “In spite of the massive historical power of the African American attorney, someone has convinced this powerful group, among others, that their job is to network with each other and prepare themselves to become well-trained tools of corporate America.”

    Mr. Watkins, isn’t the very school system they all attended (public and private, primary and secondary) largely responsible for indoctrinating their and many other young minds into this type of thinking?

    “The Civil Rights Movement did not occur just so we could find a way to fit into a world of lackluster social impotence.”

    In hindsight, isn’t that EXACTLY what they (the civil rights movement) did?

    Mr. Watkins, for someone who claims to bestow knowledge on the youth, you sure come off as quite clueless far too often!

  • http://science.articleberry.com/how-does-my-dna-work- How Does My DNA Work?

    [...] [...]

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/MR_NANASTROKER/ MR_NANASTROKER

    LMAO

    I thought they FIRED this ninja by now

    Kudos moniqTee
    But just like _A_ says…they are allowing themselves 2 RELY on a system that has been set in CONCRETE for ages……dealing with the problem of “WHY” and relying on the same “WHY” is the Subject/Topic/Detail 2 ponder

  • http://www.rapgodfathers.com/forum/latest-news/608404-2-10-dr-boyce-black-law-student-association-does-what-again.html#post7681037 2/10 DR. BOYCE: The Black Law Student Association Does What Again? – Rap GodFathers Community

    [...] [...]

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/jznryn/ jznryn

    I’m not a law student and don’t know Dr. Boyce like some of you all. I do have law student and lawyer friends, Black and White. In regards to BLSA, from the outside looking in, seems to be a simply networking organization (that and hooking up). I have yet to see the local organization take on long term project that helps the Black community. Remember this is the outside looking in. In regards to their White counterparts I see them volunteering their time to the Black community which I think is great, but when they talk to me they ask me “why aren’t there more Black law students and Lawyers (BLS&L) doing the same”, just like the Innocence Project.

    I’m not you so I don’t live your life. But I hope you can take what Dr. Boyce is saying and let it make you better not bitter. Even though his words seem harsh at times, I think the main issue was he wanted this incredible organization to do more, to step out its comfort zone. I don’t see what’s wrong with the organization taking up a charge and doing some Black community services.

    Let’s be honest, if those White firms said they wanted Blacks who volunteered time Black communities. Most likely all those who said they didn’t have the time, would magically find it.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/WDCGirl/ WDCGirl

    If you want to see what BLSA students are capable of doing and what they *are* doing, look to the local chapters. The National BLSA requires chapters to engage in a significant amount of community service and most do. The chapter I’m most familiar with not engages in mentoring, fixing-up projects, and the provision of free legal services, among others.

    Keep in mind that NBLSA is a student-run organization and that all students’ first priority is to do well in school. Participation in BLSA helps create the leaders that its members will be once they graduate.

  • http://attraction.articleberry.com/your-life-and-prosperity-are-in-your-reputation- Your Life and Prosperity Are In Your Reputation!

    [...] [...]

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/kirleen/ kirleen

    NBLSA has lost its perspective. Remember this is an organization with the most brilliant legal minds in our country. Dr. Boyce, there are so many impressive students like Melinda Hightower. She is just one in a room of hundreds like her; I won’t name them all only because there are some my son did not personally introduce me to. I first heard about this organization from my son when he went to Thomas Jefferson Law School in San Diego. He had this insatiable appetite for volunteer work with this organization. Like you said: Potential, Potential, Potential! Not just Ms. Hightower or my son, but so many others–they all want to change the world. It’s what we talk to our children about; we feel it, we live it: changing the world. (Sometimes we try to live vicariously through our children, this time its a good thing) It scares me that you think someone has convinced this powerful group, among others, that their job is to network with others and prepare themselves to become well trained tools of Corp America. (I unfortunately agree with you) All that power and our men and women lose perspective of their volunteer goals. The NBLSA needs to stop being weak, and set a strong example for our young Attorneys. Their values should be measured by their meaningful impact on African American professionals.

    You talk about being a wee bit disappointed in their lack of participation in social, racial, and legal issues. I, as a Mom of one of these professionals, am tremendously disappointed that their core values have so drastically changed from making a world difference, to making a personal financial difference. Don’t get me wrong, in the climate we live, that is very important. We have student loans to repay, and so on and so on. But we need to constantly instill in our children the need to give back and help others, especially in the minority and under privilege community. We as black people have a habit of not helping our people up that proverbial ladder, and instead we kick the ladder down so that no one else can get up. It’s past time to break that cycle and take examples from other cultures.

    This organization has to understand how important, and influential they are to our young people and get back to their grass roots commitment of uplifting and changing the world, one project @ a time, no matter how politically incorrect it may be. Thank you for your article on the The Innocence Project. For those of you who are not aware, this is one of many true stories of an African American that was exonerated by DNA evidence for a crime he was wrongfully convicted of 33 years ago. He got the news 28 years after he was released on parole for an alleged raping of a Rochester woman in 1976. “There goes for the grace of God, one of our Sons” The exoneration came from the work of the The Innocence Project affiliated with the Cardozo School of Law. NBLSA, WE ARE AWAITING YOUR ARRIVAL BACK HOME.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Justicenowornever/ Justicenowornever

    While Dr. Boyce offers some interesting sentiments on the level of social activism by NBLSA and other black professional organizations, such sentiments are too broad, general, and in some cases, blatantly incorrect.

    NBLSA, the largest student run organization, prides itself on increasing the level social advocacy, awareness, and activism in the Black community on a local, regional, and national level through programs such as Census 2010, advocating on behalf of Student Lending legislation reform (which adversely affects African American students), implementing a College Student Division (which strives to improve the pipeline of black students in law school by provides pre-law mentoring, academic support, etc.), New Orleans Advocacy Week, Election Protection, and the list goes on. Moreover, the article does not mention Project Haiti, NBLSA’s continued commitment to the people Haiti, which was implemented BEFORE the natural disaster.

    In as much, NBLSA is not only at the conversation table on key legal and social issues with the black community (through its active and vocal and involvement within the ABA and other liaisons), but encourages its members to be a stronghold in implementing change on a broad and narrow (grassroots level). In a fiscal economy where African American law graduates are rarely receiving offers for public service positions (lower paying jobs), I find it hard to believe that NBLSA members sit around discussing large firm salaries, thus making this article highly distorted.

    Furthermore, if Dr. Boyce would have conversed with more students within NBLSA’s 6,000 plus membership, he would have found several hundred more students like Ms. Hightower making significant strides within their community civically and professionally.
    As with any organization, there is always room for improvement. However, such narrow interpretation of the organization’s great strides is extremely impetuous and inaccurate.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/Justicenowornever/ Justicenowornever

    **Please excuse the typographical errors in the previous post.**

    While Dr. Boyce offers some interesting sentiments on the level of social activism by NBLSA and other black professional organizations, such sentiments are too broad, general, and in some cases, blatantly incorrect.

    NBLSA, the largest student run organization, prides itself on increasing the level social advocacy, awareness, and activism in the Black community on a local, regional, and national level through programs such as Census 2010, advocating on behalf of Student Lending legislation reform (which adversely affects African American students), implementing a College Student Division (which strives to improve the pipeline of black students in law school by provides pre-law mentoring, academic support, etc.), New Orleans Advocacy Week, Election Protection, Lobby Week, CBC Weekend, and the list goes on. Moreover, the article does not mention Project Haiti, NBLSA’s continued commitment to the people of Haiti, which was implemented BEFORE the recent natural disaster.

    In as much, NBLSA is not only at the conversation table on key legal and social issues with the black community (through its active and vocal involvement within the ABA and other organizations), but encourages its members to be a stronghold in implementing change on a broad and narrow (grassroots level). In a fiscal economy where African American law graduates are rarely receiving offers for public service positions (lower paying jobs), I find it hard to believe that NBLSA members sit around discussing large firm salaries, thus making this article highly distorted.

    Furthermore, if Dr. Boyce would have conversed with more students within NBLSA’s 6,000 plus membership, he would have found several hundred more students like Ms. Hightower making significant strides within their community civically and professionally.

    As with any organization, there is always room for improvement. However, such narrow interpretation of the organization’s great strides is extremely impetuous and erroneous. For more accurate information on the National Black Law Students Association, visit http://www.nblsa.org.

  • http://www.blackplanet.com/sasmithlaw/ sasmithlaw

    If this was supposed to be a call to action, he didn’t do a good job. Clearly, most people don’t understand the plight of being a black law student, ie. first getting in, next the fierce academic competition, financial strains of student loans before, during and after, and of course the scarcity of blacks in law school in general. Black students do well enough just graduating, let alone placing the “social savior” albatross around our necks. NBLSA is THE REASON most black students do graduate through it’s tutoring sessions at the local level. As the only true support system most black students know, Dr. Watkins has missed the ball and painted NBLSA in the most unflattering light. If NBLSA was created for solely networking purposes, it does an infinitely greater service than his article did, because at least we have come together in a positive fashion and had a meeting of the minds regarding our social obligations which we individually and collectively are able to carry on within the National Bar Association among other avenues after graduation. The social activism and projects NBLSA encourages, produces, and supports are too numerous to name, but the organization has been at the forefront of those issues, legal and otherwise, that are most important to blacks. Could NBLSA do more? Of course, but then again every organization can, however I have never seen any volunteer organization operate at maximum, flawless efficiency. Besides, NBLSA has a turnover rate due to graduation (remember, that is a law student’s primary goal) that makes it impossible to ever do so. I would expect a scholar to conduct better research and give an accurate assessment of this great organization. No good can come from finger pointing based on over-generalizations and gross factual inaccuracies. I am offended by this article and so are many of my fellow former NBLSA members. Next, time he would do well to let sleeping dogs lie

  • http://discounteddesignershoes.net designer shoes

    You should check this out…

    [...] Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well [...]……

  • http://famousbrandsale.com/ brand sale

    Websites you should visit…

    [...]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]……

  • http://burach-bhadi90.insanejournal.com premature ejaculation

    Check this out…

    [...] that is the end of this article. Here you’ll find some sites that we think you’ll appreciate, just click the links over[...]……

  • http://dracus633.insanejournal.com premature ejaculation

    Visitor recommendations…

    [...]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[...]……

  • http://vedic735.insanejournal.com last longer

    Gems form the internet…

    [...]very few websites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]……

  • http://macedon688.livejournal.com lasting longer in bed

    Recent Blogroll Additions……

    [...]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[...]……

  • http://thisbe947.typepad.com lasting longer in bed

    Visitor recommendations…

    [...]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[...]……

  • http://publishviews.com/gloria-anzaldua-resource latinas

    Cool sites…

    [...]we came across a cool site that you might enjoy. Take a look if you want[...]……

  • http://einstein.drexel.edu/liki/index.php/User_talk:Kassannasq ipad

    Totally free a legal judgment…

    Hello therealso certainly on that point there andcheers for the data�I�ve definitelyselected upanythingdifferent bysuitablehereI doon the other hand expertise a number oftechnicalconcerns usingthis specificinternet site,considering thatWhenIreallye…

  • http://movies http://beneficialmoviesofalltimes304.blinkweb.com

    Visitor recommendations…

    [...]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[...]……

  • http://azael48.insanejournal.com/ movies online

    Awesome website…

    [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]……

  • http://kaos889.xanga.com/ adult blog

    Great website…

    [...]we like to honor many other internet sites on the web, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[...]……

  • http://ricabooracker956.xanga.com/ movies online

    Visitor recommendations…

    [...]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[...]……

  • http://www.avvo.com/attorneys/60601-il-hall-adams-1127229.html Trazodone

    Great article…

    Lovely just what I was looking for….

  • http://freeipad2now.com/free-ipad-2-faq/ http://freeipad2now.com/free-ipad-2-faq/

    ……

    My wife and i have been now contented that Jordan managed to finish up his analysis via the ideas he acquired from your weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to simply find yourself giving out secrets and techniques that many some others have been making…

blog comments powered by Disqus
?>